The Law That Protects You When You Are Injured in a Shop, Gym, Restaurant, or Public Space.
0800 652 0586
By David Healey, Senior Solicitor | April 2026
WHAT YOU SHOULD KNOW
The Occupiers’ Liability Act is the law that decides what duty a shop, gym, restaurant, leisure centre, or any other public venue owes to the people inside it.
- The 1957 Act applies to lawful visitors and sets a high duty of care
- The 1984 Act applies to uninvited people and sets a lower duty
- A business cannot avoid this duty with a warning sign or a disclaimer
- In 2023, a national leisure club was fined £2.55 million for failing its duty
- Carter and Carter Solicitors handles public place accident claims across England and Wales at a published fee of 10% when settled without court proceedings
You walked into a supermarket. You slipped on a wet floor. You broke your wrist. The manager said they had just mopped. You went home thinking it was bad luck.
It was not bad luck. Under the law in England and Wales, every business that opens its doors to the public owes a duty of care the moment a person walks through them. That duty is written into a specific piece of legislation called the Occupiers’ Liability Act. There are actually two of them: the 1957 Act and the 1984 Act. Between them, they cover every situation where someone is injured on another person’s or business’s premises.
Yet most people who are hurt in a shop, a gym, a restaurant, or a leisure centre have never heard of them. That gap between the law and the public’s awareness of it is what this post is here to close.
What Does the Occupiers’ Liability Act 1957 Actually Say?
The 1957 Act applies to every person who enters premises as a lawful visitor. A shopper in a supermarket. A diner in a restaurant. A member at a gym. A guest at a hotel. A swimmer at a leisure centre. All lawful visitors. All protected by the same duty.
Section 2(2) of the Act defines that duty. The occupier must take such care as is reasonable to see that the visitor will be reasonably safe in using the premises for the purposes for which they were invited to be there.
In plain language: the business must make sure you are safe while you are doing what you came to do. If you came to shop, the floors must be safe to walk on. If you came to swim, the pool must be supervised properly. If you came to eat, the chairs must not collapse underneath you.
THE NUMBERS
604,000 non-fatal workplace and public place injuries per year
According to the HSE’s 2023/24 annual statistics, slips, trips, and falls remain the single most common cause of non-fatal injury in the UK. Many of these happen not at work but in public premises: shops, restaurants, leisure centres, and hotels. Each one raises the same question. Did the occupier take reasonable care?
The 1957 Act and the 1984 Act. Which One Applies to Me?
Most people injured in public places are covered by the 1957 Act because they are lawful visitors. The 1984 Act exists for a different situation: people who enter premises without permission. The distinction matters because the duty owed to each group is different.
If you were injured while shopping, eating out, swimming, using a gym, staying in a hotel, or visiting any premises you were invited into, the 1957 Act is almost certainly the one that applies. The duty owed to you is the higher standard.
SOMETHING MOST PEOPLE DON’T KNOW
A business cannot exclude its liability for personal injury caused by negligence. The Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 makes this a statutory prohibition. Every gym disclaimer, every leisure centre waiver, every “enter at your own risk” sign is legally incapable of removing the occupier’s duty of care for personal injury. It does not matter what the small print says. An Act of Parliament overrides it.
The same applies to warning signs. A wet floor sign does not automatically discharge the duty under the 1957 Act. Section 2(4)(a) says a warning only discharges the duty if it was enough, in all the circumstances, to enable the visitor to be reasonably safe. A sign propped against a wall ten metres from the hazard does not meet that test. The question is always whether the warning was actually enough to keep you safe. Not whether a sign existed somewhere in the building.
A Leisure Club Fined £2.55 Million. What the Court Found.
In August 2023, David Lloyd Leisure Club Limited was fined £2.55 million at Leeds Crown Court after pleading guilty to breaching Section 3 of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974. The prosecution was brought by Leeds City Council following a tragedy at one of the company’s clubs.
The court heard that the club had inadequate lifeguarding arrangements in place. A single 17-year-old member of staff had been expected to supervise 50 swimmers. The company’s own risk assessments were described as inadequate and unsuitable. This was not a one-off failure. The company had previously been fined £330,000 for an earlier incident at a different club.
What the David Lloyd Case Tells Us About Duty of Care
The occupier: David Lloyd Leisure Club Limited, a national chain
The court: Leeds Crown Court, August 2023
The charge: Breach of Section 3, Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974
The plea: Guilty
The fine: £2.55 million (starting point of £2.9 million, reduced for guilty plea)
The history: Previous fine of £330,000 for an earlier incident at a different club
The case illustrates what happens when an occupier fails to take the duty of care seriously. The law does not just create a right to claim compensation after an injury. It also creates criminal liability when the failure is serious enough. The £2.55 million fine reflected the scale: a large commercial operator, a foreseeable risk, a known history, and inadequate action to prevent harm.
I Was Hurt in a Public Place. Does It Really Matter Where It Happened?
It matters because the type of premises shapes the specific risks the occupier should have assessed. But the legal duty is the same wherever you are. The 1957 Act applies to all lawful visitors on all premises.
What changes is the evidence. A wet floor in a supermarket raises questions about the cleaning schedule. A broken chair in a restaurant raises questions about maintenance records. An equipment failure at a gym raises questions about servicing and risk assessments. In each case, the core question is identical: did the occupier take reasonable care to make the premises safe for the visitor?
“The cleaning schedule is the document we request first in every supermarket slip case. If they cannot produce one, or it shows a gap of two hours before the accident, that single piece of paper changes the entire claim.”
David Healey, Senior Solicitor, Carter & Carter Solicitors
But I Signed a Disclaimer. Does That Mean I Cannot Claim?
A Disclaimer Cannot Override an Act of Parliament
The Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 prevents businesses from using contract terms to exclude or restrict liability for death or personal injury caused by negligence. This is not a grey area. It is a statutory prohibition. Gym membership forms, leisure centre terms and conditions, and activity waivers cannot lawfully exclude the occupier’s liability for negligence.
This is one of the most common reasons people do not pursue a claim. They assume the disclaimer they signed means they gave up their rights. They did not. The law does not allow it.
If a business was negligent and you were injured, the fact that you signed a form with small print about “accepting the risks” does not prevent you from claiming. The Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 makes that explicit.
“The biggest misconception in public place claims is that a signed waiver or disclaimer takes away your rights. It does not. The Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 is an Act of Parliament. A piece of paper from a gym or a leisure centre cannot override it. Once people understand that, everything changes.”
David Healey, Senior Solicitor, Carter & Carter Solicitors
What Should I Do After an Accident in a Public Place?
Five Steps to Protect Your Right to Claim
Step 1: Report the accident. Ask the business to record it in their accident book. Take a photograph of the entry if possible.
Step 2: Photograph the scene. The wet floor, the broken equipment, the uneven surface, the missing sign. Do this before anyone cleans it up or fixes it.
Step 3: Get the names of any witnesses. Other customers, staff members, anyone who saw what happened.
Step 4: See a doctor. A&E, your GP, or a walk-in centre. The medical record creates a link between the accident and your injury.
Step 5: Contact a solicitor who handles public place accident claims. Do not accept any offer from the business directly. A direct offer is almost always lower than what your claim is worth.
YOUR RIGHTS AT A GLANCE
Three things the law says about your situation
1. The occupier owed you a duty of care under the Occupiers’ Liability Act 1957. If they failed in that duty and you were injured, you have a right to claim compensation.
2. A warning sign or a disclaimer does not remove that duty. Under the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, a business cannot exclude liability for personal injury caused by negligence.
3. You have three years from the date of the accident to bring a claim under the Limitation Act 1980. But the sooner you act, the stronger your evidence will be.
YOUR CLAIM JOURNEY
What Happens After You Call
1
Free Call
Speak to a senior solicitor directly. Honest assessment on the spot.
2
Evidence
Photos, witness details, medical records. We guide you on what to gather.
3
Claim Filed
Your solicitor contacts the occupier’s insurer. You do nothing.
4
Negotiation
Most public place claims settle in 4 to 8 months without court.
5
Settlement
Compensation paid directly to you within 14 to 28 days of agreement.
Where Were You When You Were Injured?
Find the Guide That Matches Your Situation
Carter & Carter’s Fee Structure
10%
When your claim is settled
without court proceedings
(approximately 99% of claims
do not proceed to a final court hearing)
25%
Only if court proceedings
become necessary
Related Guides
Tripping and Slipping in Public Places →
Wet Floor Slip in a Public Place: Who Has to Prove What? →
Signed a Gym Waiver? You May Still Be Able to Claim →
Injured in a Public Place?
Speak directly to a specialist solicitor. Free. No obligation. No pressure.
David Healey is a Senior Solicitor at Carter & Carter Solicitors in Whaley Bridge, Derbyshire. Qualified in 2005, David has spent over 21 years helping people injured in public places and at work. Public place accident claims are one of the firm’s four specialist practice areas. Carter & Carter is one of very few firms in England and Wales to publish its fee structure upfront and to handle every claim personally at senior solicitor level from start to finish. Learn more about the team.