By David Healey, Senior Solicitor · Last reviewed: October 2026
Restaurant Served Nuts After a Warning
Call 0800 652 0586 for a free chat
| The situation | You told a restaurant, café, pub or takeaway about your nut or peanut allergy, and it still served you food containing nuts. We act for adults, not on behalf of children |
|---|---|
| Why it is usually a claim | Once the restaurant knew, it had to take reasonable care to keep nuts out of your food |
| Who pays | The restaurant’s insurer, usually. Not the member of staff who served you |
| Time limit | 3 years from the date of the incident |
| Typical compensation | Most of our claims like this settle for £2,500 to £3,500 before our fee for the reaction itself, plus lost earnings and expenses |
| Typical time to settle | 3 to 6 months where the business accepts it was at fault. Longer if it denies responsibility |
| Court | About eight in ten of our successful claims settle before court proceedings are issued. Around 1 in 100 needs a final hearing |
| Our fee | Nothing if your claim fails, with two exceptions set out in your agreement (see the full fee detail). 10%, VAT included, if it settles before court proceedings are issued. Full fee details |
1Can You Claim When a Restaurant Ignored Your Warning? · 4 questionsThe restaurant served me nuts after I told them about my allergy. Can I claim? · Why does telling them make my claim stronger? · Does it matter whether it was a restaurant, café, pub or takeaway? · Is it worth claiming if I recovered quickly?↓2How Restaurants Get It Wrong, and What They Say · 6 questionsHow do restaurants get it wrong after a warning? · What will the restaurant say, and does it stand up? · What if they say I never told them? · What if the waiter says they don’t remember me? · Does it matter that the restaurant has a good food hygiene rating? · I’ve eaten there before without any problems. Does that matter?↓3Proving You Warned Them · 4 questionsHow do I prove I told them about my allergy? · What should I do now? · Can I claim without the receipt or a witness? · The restaurant has offered me money. Should I accept it?↓4What Your Claim Is Worth, and How Long It Takes · 2 questionsHow much compensation if a restaurant served me nuts after a warning? · How long does a claim like this take?↓5Our Fee, and Who Handles Your Claim · 2 questionsHow much will it cost me? · Who will handle my claim?↓
Can You Claim When a Restaurant Ignored Your Warning?
1.1The restaurant served me nuts after I told them about my allergy. Can I claim?
Usually yes. Once you told them, the restaurant knew it had to keep nuts out of your food. If it served you nuts anyway and you had a reaction, it is usually responsible, and its insurer usually pays.
Tap for the full answer
The restaurant served me nuts after I told them about my allergy. Can I claim? In most cases, yes. You did what you were supposed to do: you told them. From that moment the restaurant knew about the danger, and it had to take reasonable care to give you food that was safe for you. Serving you nuts anyway is a failure on its part, not yours.
It is also the situation most of our nut allergy clients are in. In our experience it is one of the clearest kinds of allergy claim, because the restaurant cannot say it did not know. The claim is against the business, and its insurer usually deals with it and pays, not the member of staff who served you.
Not sure your situation fits? Call us on 0800 652 0586. We will tell you whether we can take your claim on, and if we cannot, we will say so.
1.2Why does telling them make my claim stronger?
Because it takes away the restaurant’s easiest answer. It cannot say it did not know, and anything that went wrong after you told it is its own failure.
Tap for the full answer
A restaurant must always be able to tell you accurately which dishes contain nuts or peanuts: they are two of the 14 allergens food businesses must give information about under food information law, including the Food Information Regulations 2014. Once you tell it about your allergy, it also knows that getting it wrong could seriously harm you, and the care it must take rises with that knowledge.
So the question stops being whether the restaurant knew, and becomes what went wrong after you told it. That is a question about its own staff and systems. How you warned them affects how easily that is proved:
| You told the person who took your order | Usually enough on its own. Your account is evidence, and the restaurant’s own records often back it up. |
|---|---|
| Someone with you heard you say it | Helps a lot. An independent witness to the conversation. |
| You told the manager or the chef | Helps a lot. Senior staff knew, so the restaurant knew. |
| It is written on the order, the bill or the booking | The clearest proof there is. Photograph it. |
| You put it in an online booking or app order | The clearest proof there is. Screenshot it before it disappears. |
1.3Does it matter whether it was a restaurant, café, pub or takeaway?
No. Every food business that serves you after being told about your allergy owes you the same care. We have a separate guide for each kind of place.
Tap for the full answer
No. A café, pub, hotel, takeaway, wedding caterer or dessert bar owes the same duty as a restaurant once you have told it about your allergy. The evidence differs a little from place to place, so we have written a guide for each: cafés and coffee shops, takeaways, delivery apps, hotels, weddings and catered events and milkshake and dessert bars.
One point that often causes confusion: Natasha’s Law is about labelling food that is packed on the premises before you order it, such as a café sandwich. A meal cooked to order after you have told the staff about your allergy is covered by the general allergen rules and the restaurant’s duty of care, not by Natasha’s Law. Your claim does not depend on it. Our guide to Natasha’s Law explains what it does cover.
1.4Is it worth claiming if I recovered quickly?
Usually yes. A reaction you recovered from still has a value, and it is worth more if you needed emergency treatment or have been anxious about eating out since.
Tap for the full answer
How serious the reaction was affects how much your claim is worth, not whether you can claim. A reaction treated with antihistamines at home or by a GP can still be claimed. Our guide to mild reactions with no hospital visit explains more, and our guide to nut allergy claims sets out the full picture.
How Restaurants Get It Wrong, and What They Say
2.1How do restaurants get it wrong after a warning?
Usually in one of six ways: the warning never reaches the kitchen, the note is missed, cross-contact, the wrong plate, nuts hidden in a recipe, or a change of staff.
Tap for the full answer
How do restaurants get it wrong after a warning? These are the six ways we see most often. You do not need to know which one happened: it is enough that you told them and were served nuts. Finding out how it went wrong is part of our job, and the restaurant’s own records usually show it.
2.2What will the restaurant say, and does it stand up?
Usually that the waiter didn’t pass it on, that it was cross-contamination, or that you weren’t clear. Those are explanations of the restaurant’s own failure, not defences to it.
Tap for the full answer
Restaurants and their insurers tend to give the same few explanations. Most of them describe how the restaurant failed, rather than showing that it did not.
There is one real exception. If the staff warned you that a dish was not safe for you, or might contain nuts, and you chose to eat it anyway, that can reduce or defeat a claim. We will tell you at the start if it applies.
2.3What if they say I never told them?
It is a defence we hear often, and it can often be answered: with anyone who was with you, the booking or order notes, and the restaurant’s own records.
Tap for the full answer
Sometimes a restaurant says you never mentioned your allergy at all. Your own account is evidence, and it is often backed up by the people you were with, by notes on the booking, the order or the bill, and by what the restaurant itself wrote down or failed to write down. Our guide to what to do when the restaurant denies you told them goes through it in detail.
2.4What if the waiter says they don’t remember me?
That is common, and it rarely matters. The question is what you said and what the restaurant recorded, not what one member of staff remembers months later.
Tap for the full answer
Staff move on and busy shifts blur together, so a waiter not remembering is normal. The evidence that counts is your own account, anyone who was with you, the order and booking records, and the timing of your reaction in the medical notes. If you are worried your evidence is thin, call us on 0800 652 0586 and we will tell you where you stand.
2.5Does it matter that the restaurant has a good food hygiene rating?
No. A food hygiene rating looks at cleanliness, food storage and management. It is not a check on whether staff passed on your warning, so it does not weaken your claim.
Tap for the full answer
No. Food hygiene ratings are based on hygiene, the condition of the premises and how food safety is managed on the day of an inspection. They do not tell you whether a warning about your allergy reached the kitchen on the day you ate there. A five-star rating does not change what happened to you.
2.6I’ve eaten there before without any problems. Does that matter?
No, it does not weaken your claim. Trusting a restaurant that had got it right before was reasonable, and it shows the restaurant knew how to keep you safe.
Tap for the full answer
No. Going back to a restaurant that had looked after you before was a reasonable thing to do, and you were still entitled to rely on it to take care this time. If anything, it shows the restaurant was capable of serving you safely. If you are unsure how this affects your claim, call us on 0800 652 0586.
Proving You Warned Them
3.1How do I prove I told them about my allergy?
With whatever you have: a note on the order, bill or booking, the people who were with you, and your own account. The restaurant’s records often fill the gaps.
Tap for the full answer
How do I prove I told them about my allergy? Start with what you have. These are the things that help most, roughly in order. Few people have all of them.
We then ask the restaurant for its order records, allergen information, procedures and staff training records, which often show what went wrong. Our nut allergy evidence guide covers every type of evidence in more detail.
3.2What should I do now?
Look after your health first. Then photograph the receipt, menu and dish, get the names of anyone who was with you, write down what you said and to whom, and keep your medical records.
Tap for the full answer
What should I do now? Your health comes first: use your adrenaline pen if you need it and call 999. The NHS advises calling 999 whenever an adrenaline pen has been used, even if you start to feel better. Once you are safe:
CCTV is often recorded over within weeks, so the sooner we ask for it, the better. Call us on 0800 652 0586 when you are ready.
3.3Can I claim without the receipt or a witness?
Usually yes. A bank or card statement proves you were there, and your own account of what you told them is evidence. Many claims start with exactly that.
Tap for the full answer
Yes. Most people do not keep receipts, and many eat out alone or with people who did not hear the conversation. A bank or card statement proves you were there. Your own account of what you told them is evidence in its own right, and the restaurant’s records, which we can ask for, often support it. Our evidence guide explains how to prove a visit without a receipt.
3.4The restaurant has offered me money. Should I accept it?
Not before you know what your claim is worth. A refund of your bill does not usually affect a claim, but accepting money as a full and final settlement can end it.
Tap for the full answer
Restaurants sometimes offer a refund, vouchers or a small payment soon after a reaction. It may be well meant, but it is rarely what the claim is worth, and if you accept anything described as a full and final settlement you may not be able to claim later. Before you agree to anything, call us on 0800 652 0586. If no solicitor is acting for you, we will look at whether we can take your claim on. No charge, no obligation.
What Your Claim Is Worth, and How Long It Takes
4.1How much compensation if a restaurant served me nuts after a warning?
Most of our claims like this settle for £2,500 to £3,500 before our fee for the reaction itself, with lost earnings and expenses on top. Reactions with longer-lasting symptoms can be worth more.
Tap for the full answer
How much compensation if a restaurant served me nuts after a warning? Most of our claims like this settle for £2,500 to £3,500 before our fee for the reaction itself. A milder reaction treated at home can be worth less, and one with longer-lasting symptoms can be worth more. Lost earnings and expenses, such as prescriptions or replacing an adrenaline pen you had to use, are added on top.
The two reported nut allergy cases we ran sit in that range. Fewins v Brooks Hotel Ltd (County Court at Canterbury, 2021), where staff were told and still served peanuts, and Blane v Kwai Hau Ha (County Court, 2020), a severe reaction to a meal containing nuts, were each awarded £2,600. That is about £3,500 and £3,750 in today’s money. Both claimants had a week to recover physically and were anxious about eating out for a year.
These are guides, not promises. Our pages on nut allergy compensation amounts and nut allergy claims show how the figures work.
4.2How long does a claim like this take?
Most of our claims like this settle within 3 to 6 months where the business accepts it was at fault. Longer if it denies responsibility.
Tap for the full answer
Most of our claims like this settle within 3 to 6 months where the business accepts it was at fault, and about eight in ten of our successful claims settle before court proceedings are issued. A claim the restaurant denies takes longer. You have three years from the date of the incident to start court proceedings (Limitation Act 1980), but the evidence is easiest to get early. Our guides to the claims process and time limits go through it in detail.
Our Fee, and Who Handles Your Claim
5.1How much will it cost me?
Nothing if your claim fails, except in two situations set out in your agreement. If it succeeds, Carter and Carter Solicitors takes 10% of your compensation, VAT included, if it settles before court proceedings are issued, or 25% if proceedings are issued.
Tap for the full answer
How much will a restaurant nut allergy claim cost with us? Nothing up front, and nothing if your claim fails. If it succeeds, we take just 10% of your compensation, VAT included, if it settles before court proceedings are issued, as about eight in ten of our successful claims do. If proceedings have to be issued, our fee is 25%.
Nothing else is deducted from your compensation. We do not add VAT on top, and we do not put an insurance premium on your claim as standard: that is your choice, and for most claims like this we do not recommend it, because the rules already protect you from paying the other side’s costs if you lose, with two exceptions. You could have to pay if you turn down an offer we advised you in writing to accept and the court then awards you no more, or if a court finds you were dishonest about something central to the claim. Both are set out in plain words in your agreement, which you read in your own time before you sign.
Why 10%? Most of our claims settle without going to court, so there is less work to pay for. And with just two of us running the firm, our costs are low. So we do not need to take 25%. In our experience almost every no win no fee firm takes 25%. See what no win no fee solicitors take.
5.2Who will handle my claim?
Chris Carter or David Healey, the two senior solicitors at Carter and Carter Solicitors, from start to finish. No call centre and no junior.
Tap for the full answer
Carter and Carter Solicitors is deliberately small. There are two of us: Chris Carter, who qualified in 1993, and David Healey, who qualified in 2005, and both of us have only ever done personal injury work. One of us deals with your claim after the first call, through to the day you are paid, by phone, email and post, wherever you live in England and Wales. There is no call centre and no junior case handler, and you have your solicitor’s direct line and email.
We have 256 five-star Google reviews. You can read what our clients say.
For a free, no obligation discussion about Your Restaurant Nut Allergy Claim, simply either call us now on 0800 652 0586, email us on chris@candcsolicitors.co.uk, or complete a Free Online Enquiry and we will explain all of the options available to you.
“I can’t thank this firm enough for their support, especially Dave who handled my case with care and professionalism. After being served prawns at a restaurant despite clearly stating my allergy, I suffered a reaction leading to use of my epi pen. I reached out to four other solicitors, but all turned me away because […]
Jasmine Richards Marsh ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐











